
Chapter 9 closes volume 2 with old rifles, a supply lift, and one desperate gamble in Trost. Armin's plan blinds seven Titans just long enough for the trainees to cut them down, and when the rogue Titan finally collapses outside, the figure steaming out of its nape rewrites everything: Eren is alive.
While the rogue Titan keeps tearing through its own kind outside, the trainees trapped at headquarters dig up a cache of antiquated guns. Armin builds a strategy around them: a first team rides the lift down into the supply room to lure in the seven small Titans, fires into their eyes at close range, and a second team of seven drops from the rafters onto the blinded targets' napes. The risk gnaws at Armin, but Mikasa steadies him, reminding him that his thinking has pulled her and Eren through danger before. The trap is sprung and five of the seven strikes land clean; Sasha and Connie botch their cuts, and Mikasa and Annie finish the wounded Titans before anyone dies. With the room cleared, everyone refills their gas tanks.
As the group prepares to leave, Mikasa lingers at a window, watching other Titans swarm and eat the rogue that saved them, regretting that its secrets may be lost. Reiner argues for intervening, and Annie agrees that an allied Titan would be worth the risk, while Jean balks at spending lives on a monster. The debate ends when the rogue erupts from the pile, lunges at the very Titan that devoured Thomas Wagner, and crushes its nape between its teeth, using the corpse as a club against another before finally collapsing, spent.
Jean has barely repeated that a Titan can never be an ally when steam vents from the creature's neck and a human body emerges from the flesh: Eren, whole again despite the arm and leg he lost. Mikasa races down, wraps herself around him, and listens against his chest. The heartbeat she finds there undoes her; she carries him back to the rooftop and sobs over him while Armin notices the regenerated limbs and the others stare at the field of dead Titans, slowly grasping that Eren was the one who slaughtered them all.
Armin devises the eye-shot ambush that clears the seven Titans out of the supply room without maneuvering gear.
Mikasa and Annie save Sasha and Connie after their strikes fail.
The trainees resupply their gas and escape headquarters.
The rogue Titan kills the Titan that ate Thomas Wagner, then collapses from exhaustion.
Eren emerges alive from the rogue Titan's nape with his missing limbs restored, revealing to his classmates that he was the Titan.
The Beating of a Heart Can Be Heard closes volume 2 as its fifth chapter and the ninth of the series overall, by Hajime Isayama. It was published in Japan on May 9, 2010, with the English edition following on September 11, 2012, as part of the Wall Sealing arc. The anime adapts it in I Can Hear His Heartbeat: The Struggle for Trost, Part 4.
It follows Roar; the story continues in Where's the Left Arm?, alongside the special chapter Captain Levi.

Naruto vs Luffy with the twist nobody asked for: Luffy tickled Hinata on date night, and she kind of liked it. We break down the whole fight and commit to a winner....

There are no women on Namek. That isn't an oversight, it's the biology. Why we handed Piccolo the one thing his own species rules out, and why it had to be trap soul....
Armin devises a plan where one team lures seven small Titans in close and fires antiquated rifles into their eyes to blind them, while a second team drops from the rafters to strike the exposed napes.
After killing the Titan that ate Thomas Wagner, the rogue Titan collapses from exhaustion, and steam vents from its neck as Eren emerges alive from the nape with his lost arm and leg fully regenerated.
Mikasa races down to Eren, wraps herself around him, and listens against his chest, breaking down in tears once she hears his heartbeat and confirms he is alive.
Staring at the field of dead Titans, Armin, Jean, and the others slowly grasp that Eren was the rogue Titan who had been slaughtering other Titans to protect them.
The chapter is adapted in the anime episode I Can Hear His Heartbeat: The Struggle for Trost, Part 4.
Looking for more on The Beating of a Heart Can Be Heard? The Dragon Ball Wiki on Fandom has a dedicated page with community notes.
View on FandomThis content is original writing by Daddy Jim Headquarters based on the Dragon Ball anime series, manga, and official materials. Episode and chapter references are cited where applicable.
Character and scene imagery on this site is original artwork by Daddy Jim Headquarters, not screenshots or licensed imagery. Official cover art is used on three types of pages for editorial commentary:
Official resources:
Daddy Jim Headquarters maintains this encyclopedia. If you spot an error, a translation issue, or something that doesn't look right, let us know.