Back

I Want to See Them! Luffy's Tearful Scream

EpisodeEp. 505

Crushed by guilt over his brother's death, Luffy spirals until Jinbe forces him to weigh his grief against the bonds he still holds. From distant funerals to a confrontation on Amazon Lily, the episode steers a broken pirate back toward the will to keep going.

Adapted Chapter: Chapter 590
Character Debut: Chicken
Text Size

Summary

Ace's death continues to torment Luffy, who lies wrecked and unresponsive. Far away, Garp arrives at Foosha Village, sinking three pirate vessels along the route and promising the residents that his name alone will shield the place. Inside Makino's bar, Dadan erupts at him for standing by during the war, beating the old Marine before Makino intervenes. When Makino suggests Garp must be hurting most of all, Dadan counters that the deepest pain belongs to Luffy, who adored his brother. Overcome, Makino flees in tears at the memory of the two boys. Garp later voices his belief that Luffy slipped away alive, and Dadan, calling him a fool, swears she would back him as any kind of pirate, then bellows for him not to give in.

Text Size

Key Events

Within the New World, Shanks and what remains of Edward Newgate's crew lay both Ace and their late captain to rest. Marco offers his gratitude to Shanks for the aid, and Shanks quietly tells the absent Luffy that weeping is permitted so long as he carries on afterward. On Amazon Lily, Luffy keeps pinning Ace's death on his own frailty, brushing aside Jinbe's protests by claiming his body is his to ruin. Jinbe turns the logic against him, noting that by the same measure Ace owned his life and was free to spend it as he chose. A scuffle breaks out, and Jinbe overpowers Luffy with ease before halting him and urging him to count what remains rather than what is gone. The thought of his crew settles Luffy, who weeps and admits he longs to reunite with them.

Text Size

Notes

The adaptation shows Garp downing three ships instead of the single one from the manga, and inserts a moment of Dadan drinking ahead of his arrival. Her clash with Garp ends far earlier here than on the page, while Luffy's recollections of his crew run longer, even depicting them calling out to him. A few of these visions render Franky with an ordinary nose rather than his metal one. The teaser for the following installment is trimmed shorter than usual.

Share this resource

Frequently Asked Questions

In what episode does Luffy realize he still has his crew?

This realization comes in Episode 505, when Jinbe pushes back against Luffy's despair on Amazon Lily, leading Luffy to weep and admit he longs to reunite with his crew.

What happens in One Piece Episode 505?

Episode 505 shows Luffy crushed by guilt over Ace's death until Jinbe forces him to weigh his grief against the bonds he still holds, while Garp and Dadan clash back at Foosha Village.

How does Jinbe help Luffy cope with Ace's death?

In Episode 505, Jinbe turns Luffy's own logic against him, arguing that Ace was free to spend his life as he chose, then overpowers Luffy in a scuffle and urges him to count what remains rather than what is gone.

How does Garp react to Ace's death in Episode 505?

Garp arrives at Foosha Village in Episode 505, sinking three pirate vessels along the way, and later voices his belief that Luffy is still alive somewhere.

How do Shanks and Whitebeard's crew honor Ace in Episode 505?

In Episode 505, Shanks and the remnants of Edward Newgate's crew lay Ace and Whitebeard to rest together in the New World, with Shanks quietly telling the absent Luffy that grief is fine as long as he keeps going.

Sources & Information

Looking for more on I Want to See Them! Luffy's Tearful Scream? The One Piece Wiki on Fandom has a dedicated page with community notes.

View on Fandom

This content is original writing by Daddy Jim Headquarters based on the One Piece anime series, manga, and official materials. Episode and chapter references are cited where applicable.

Rights holders

All rights belong to their respective owners.

Character and scene imagery on this site is original artwork by Daddy Jim Headquarters, not screenshots or licensed imagery. Official cover art is used on three types of pages for editorial commentary:

  • Movie pages: theatrical posters and key visuals, credited to Toei Animation and Toei Company.
  • Game pages: official box art for the One Piece console and mobile games, credited to Bandai Namco.
  • Manga chapter pages: Jump Comics volume covers, credited to Shueisha and Eiichiro Oda.

Help Us Keep This Wiki Accurate

Daddy Jim Headquarters maintains this encyclopedia. If you spot an error, a translation issue, or something that doesn't look right, let us know.