The Fake Straw Hat Crew was a band of impostors put together by Demalo Black to pose as Luffy's crew and cash in on their fame. They ran a short-lived recruitment scheme on Sabaody before the genuine Straw Hats returned and exposed them.
Within the Return to Sabaody Arc, these frauds serve as the central villains. Because the wider world assumed Luffy's genuine crew had died two years earlier, Black and his followers seized on that belief, dressed to resemble the originals, and staged a triumphant comeback that let them trade on the reputation the real pirates had built.
Their stolen Jolly Roger copies Luffy's skull-and-straw-hat emblem, though it is rendered in jet black. Drowsy, half-lidded eyes and a grin that sits flatter and meaner give it a nastier edge. Eight members mimic individual Straw Hats, yet Brook has no double, since his late arrival, his musical fame, and his skeletal body would make any imitation pointless. The name itself is officially rendered in translation.
Combat was never this group's strength. Their whole strategy leaned on borrowed notoriety rather than ability, so Black hid the fact that his personal bounty amounted to just 26,000,000 while gathering pirates whose reputations could carry him into the New World. He accepted only captains valued at 70,000,000 or more, eventually assembling roughly one hundred recruits across three crews, ten of them bearing bounties. This echoes how Bellamy, back in the Jaya Arc, once threw his weight around inside Mock Town.
Once the truth surfaced, the whole scheme unraveled fast. A single blow from Sentomaru's axe flattened Black, while the real Luffy dropped four impostors at once with a burst of Supreme King Haki. Treating comrades as disposable assets rather than friends, the fakes abandoned their unconscious captain, blamed him for forcing the charade, and pleaded with Caribou for mercy.
Demalo Black, called Three-Tongued, impersonated Luffy as an obese man quick to shoot anyone who annoyed him. Manjaro stood in for Zoro, Chocolat for Nami, Mounblutain for Sogeking, Drip for Sanji, Nora Gitsune (a pet fox) for Chopper, Cocoa for Robin, and Turco for Franky. The recruits included the brothers Caribou and Coribou, feared for slaying Marines, both of whom signed on hoping to murder the Straw Hats from within; Caribou was wanted for 210,000,000, while his brother's price sat at 190,000,000. Albion and Lip Doughty were likewise among the higher-bounty captains drawn in by the ruse.

When I first decided to commit to watching One Piece seriously, I knew I was embarking on one of anime's longest and most beloved series. With over 100...

The transformation everyone knows, the follow-up question nobody would touch. Why we made a smooth R&B track about the golden glow Dragon Ball never talks about....
The Fake Straw Hat Crew was a group of impostors assembled by Demalo Black who dressed to resemble Luffy's real crew and staged a false comeback on Sabaody. They traded on the reputation the genuine Straw Hats had built while the world believed the originals had died.
The Fake Straw Hat Crew was exposed once the real Straw Hats returned to Sabaody. Sentomaru knocked out Demalo Black with a single blow, Luffy dropped four impostors at once using Haki, and the remaining fakes abandoned their unconscious captain and begged Caribou for mercy.
Demalo Black played the role of Luffy in the Fake Straw Hat Crew, posing as an obese impostor captain who was quick to shoot anyone who annoyed him. He hid the fact that his real bounty was only 26,000,000 while recruiting pirates with far bigger reputations.
Manjaro stood in for Zoro, Chocolat for Nami, Mounblutain for Sogeking, Drip for Sanji, Nora Gitsune the fox for Chopper, Cocoa for Robin, and Turco for Franky. No one imitated Brook, since his late arrival and skeletal body made a fake version pointless.
The Fake Straw Hat Crew relied on borrowed notoriety rather than real strength, so once the genuine Straw Hats confronted them, the fraud collapsed instantly. The impostors treated each other as disposable, abandoning their captain and blaming him the moment things went wrong.
Looking for more on Fake Straw Hat Crew? The One Piece Wiki on Fandom has a dedicated page with community notes.
View on FandomThis content is original writing by Daddy Jim Headquarters based on the One Piece anime series, manga, and official materials. Episode and chapter references are cited where applicable.
Character and scene imagery on this site is original artwork by Daddy Jim Headquarters, not screenshots or licensed imagery. Official cover art is used on three types of pages for editorial commentary:
Official resources:
Daddy Jim Headquarters maintains this encyclopedia. If you spot an error, a translation issue, or something that doesn't look right, let us know.